November 17, 2023

by Taylor Rippy

Why are natural Christmas trees better?

As December unfolds, households worldwide grapple with a classic festive dilemma: to choose a natural Christmas tree or to invest in an artificial one. While the convenience and longevity of artificial trees are often touted, there’s an undeniable charm and array of benefits linked to real trees. This essay delves into the timeless appeal of natural Christmas trees and why they may be a better choice over their synthetic counterparts.

1. Environmental Benefits: At the heart of the debate is the environmental impact. Natural trees, being biodegradable, can be composted or recycled at the end of the festive season, leaving a minimal carbon footprint. In contrast, artificial trees, primarily made from PVC and metals, take hundreds of years to decompose when they’re discarded. To truly match the eco-friendliness of a real tree, one would need to use an artificial tree for around ten years.
2. Air Quality: Real trees, during their growth phase, act as carbon sinks, absorbing CO2 and releasing fresh oxygen, playing a part in combating climate change. When brought indoors, they can also improve air quality. Artificial trees, on the other hand, can sometimes release volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which aren’t ideal for indoor environments.
3. Economic Impact on Local Communities: Purchasing a natural Christmas tree often supports local farmers and small businesses. In the U.S. alone, the Christmas tree farming industry employs over 100,000 people. Buying real trees helps sustain these jobs and bolsters local economies.
4. The Authentic Festive Experience: There’s an intangible magic associated with the ritual of selecting a natural Christmas tree—walking through rows of trees, feeling the needles, and breathing in the fresh pine scent. This immersive experience, often wrapped in layers of family tradition, is something artificial trees simply cannot replicate.
5. Variability and Uniqueness: Each natural tree is distinct in its form, offering a unique silhouette, texture, and scent. This variability ensures that no two Christmases feel the same, allowing each year’s celebrations to have a distinct charm.
6. Sustainability Efforts: With the spotlight on sustainable farming, many Christmas tree farmers are adopting practices that ensure trees are grown in an eco-friendly manner. For each tree cut, one to three saplings are often planted in its place, ensuring a continuous cycle.

In conclusion, while artificial trees offer certain conveniences, the benefits of natural Christmas trees—ranging from their environmental impact to the sheer joy they bring—cannot be understated. Choosing a real tree is not just about preserving a tradition; it’s about embracing sustainability, supporting communities, and indulging in the authentic essence of the festive season.